Thanksgiving is a time for gratitude, family, and, undeniably, an abundance of incredible food. Among the festive spread, Thanksgiving pies hold a special place, marking the sweet conclusion to a memorable feast. From beloved traditional recipes passed down through generations to innovative twists that surprise and delight, the perfect pie completes any holiday dessert table. This comprehensive guide gathers our finest pie recipes, foolproof crusts, and essential tips for preparing, storing, and even freezing your pies in advance, ensuring a stress-free and deliciously memorable holiday season.
Preparing for the holiday rush can be daunting, but with these expert baking tips, you can reduce kitchen stress significantly. Learn how to master Thanksgiving menu planning, tackle make-ahead desserts, and keep your homemade pies fresh, allowing you more time to cherish moments with loved ones. Dive into our collection and discover your new favorite holiday tradition!
Traditional Thanksgiving Pies
Embrace the comforting essence of autumn with our collection of classic Thanksgiving pie recipes. These seasonal favorites are infused with rich fall flavors like pumpkin, apple, and pecan, guaranteed to bring warmth and joy to your holiday gathering. Discover the best pumpkin pies and other timeless holiday desserts that embody the spirit of the season.
Praline Pumpkin Pie
This praline pumpkin pie is always a huge hit at Thanksgiving! It takes the best of both pecan pie and classic pumpkin pie, marrying the two together for something absolutely delicious. A classic flaky crust holds a creamy pumpkin filling, beautifully topped with a crunchy brown sugar pecan crumble, offering an irresistible combination of textures and seasonal flavors.
Get the recipe here!
Crustless Pumpkin Pie
For those seeking a lighter option or a gluten-free alternative, this crustless pumpkin pie is an excellent choice. It delivers all the rich, spiced flavor of a classic pumpkin pie without the traditional crust. This recipe simplifies your holiday baking, making it perfect for guests with dietary preferences or anyone who simply adores the creamy pumpkin filling.
Get the recipe here!
Southern Pecan Pie Recipe
A true staple at many holiday tables, this Southern pecan pie boasts a buttery homemade crust and a luscious, creamy custard base. It’s generously topped with a crunchy, sweet pecan filling, creating a symphony of textures and flavors. This traditional recipe is surprisingly quick to prepare, ensuring a spectacular dessert with minimal effort.
Get the recipe here!
Apple Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
This easy-to-make apple pie features a delightful graham cracker crust, offering a pleasant crunch that perfectly complements the soft, spiced apple filling. Crowned with a brown sugar crumble, it’s a wonderfully comforting dessert that serves as a fantastic alternative to a traditional pastry crust, especially when served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Get the recipe here!
French Silk Pie
While often enjoyed year-round, French silk pie has earned its place among our traditional Thanksgiving desserts. This incredibly rich and creamy chocolate pie is a dream come true for chocolate lovers. Its silky smooth texture, deep chocolate flavor, and delicate crust make it an indulgent addition that perfectly balances the autumnal spices of other holiday offerings.
Get the recipe here!
Turtle Pie Recipe
Prepare to impress your guests with this decadent turtle pie, a surprisingly easy dessert that can be made ahead of time. Featuring a delightful graham cracker pecan crust, a rich salted caramel cream cheese layer, and a luscious chocolate caramel pecan topping, this pie combines classic flavors in a truly irresistible package.
Get the recipe here!
Beyond these, consider the timeless allure of a classic Salted Caramel Apple Pie, which perfectly captures the sweet and tart essence of fall, elevated by a rich caramel sauce and flaky crust.
Coconut Cream Pie
Indulge in a slice of tropical paradise with this rich and creamy coconut cream pie. With its luscious coconut custard filling nestled in a buttery crust and topped with fluffy whipped cream and toasted coconut, it’s a delightful, refreshing contrast to the heavier holiday dishes. This pie is a crowd-pleaser that offers an elegant touch to your dessert spread.
Get the recipe here!
Non-Traditional Thanksgiving Pies
While traditional fall flavors are cherished, adding a few unexpected delights to your Thanksgiving dessert table can make the meal even more memorable. These non-traditional pie recipes offer a refreshing twist, bringing diverse flavors and textures that might just become your family’s new favorite holiday treats.
Key Lime Pie
Brighten your holiday celebration with a zesty key lime pie. This creamy, sweet, and tangy dessert provides a wonderful contrast to richer holiday fare. Made with fresh key limes, its vibrant flavor and smooth texture make it an instant hit, often disappearing from the table in minutes!
Get the recipe here!
Lemon Sour Cream Pie
This lemon sour cream pie is a revelation, perfectly balancing sweetness with a delightful tartness, all wrapped in an extra creamy filling. A true family favorite, it’s the kind of dessert that leaves everyone asking for seconds. Its refreshing flavor profile makes it a standout amidst the usual holiday lineup.
Get the recipe here!
Banoffee Pie Recipe with Graham Cracker Crust
For banana cream pie enthusiasts, banoffee pie is an absolute must-try. This delightful dessert features a rich dulce de leche toffee layer, fresh banana slices, and a generous topping of creamy whipped cream, all nestled in a graham cracker crust. It’s a classic combination with a fresh fruit twist that’s simply irresistible.
Get the recipe here!
Cannoli Pie Recipe
Bring the beloved flavors of Italy to your Thanksgiving table with this unique cannoli pie. It perfectly captures the classic taste of sweet ricotta cheese, chocolate, and a hint of citrus in an easy-to-slice pie format. This no-bake wonder is a fantastic way to offer something truly distinctive and utterly delicious.
Get the recipe here!
No Bake Peanut Butter Pie
Peanut butter lovers rejoice! This no-bake peanut butter pie is the ultimate make-ahead dessert. Its creamy, rich filling and easy preparation make it a year-round favorite. Simply freeze it a few days in advance, then adorn with Reese’s peanut butter cups and hot fudge for a truly spectacular and effortless holiday treat.
Get the recipe here!
Biscoff Pumpkin Pie
Experience a delightful fusion of flavors with this biscoff pumpkin pie. This no-bake creation elevates the classic pumpkin pie with the warm, spiced notes of Biscoff cookie butter, complemented by traditional fall spices and a cloud of whipped cream. It’s a creamy, dreamy dessert that offers a modern and exciting spin on a holiday favorite.
Get the recipe here!
For a refreshing citrus dessert, consider a Classic Lemon Meringue Pie with its tart lemon filling and fluffy meringue. Another Southern classic that offers a layered delight is the Arkansas Possum Pie, featuring a pecan crust, cream cheese, chocolate pudding, and whipped cream layers.
Arkansas Possum Pie
This classic Arkansas Possum Pie is a delightful layered dessert that combines a shortbread pecan crust with a creamy cream cheese layer, rich chocolate pudding, and light whipped cream. These foundational flavors come together beautifully to create a satisfying and easy-to-love holiday pie, perfect for any gathering.
Get the recipe here!
Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie
Transport yourself back in time with this delicious old-fashioned banana cream pie. Featuring a Nilla wafer crust, piled high with fresh banana slices, and smothered in homemade vanilla custard, it’s a comforting and indulgent dessert. This pie is a beloved addition to any dessert table, offering a familiar yet extraordinary taste.
Get the recipe here!
S’mores Pie
Capture the nostalgic flavors of a campfire treat in pie form with this amazing s’mores pie recipe. It features a sweet graham cracker crust, a rich homemade chocolate pudding, and a topping of perfectly toasted marshmallow cream. This fun and flavorful pie is a playful yet sophisticated addition to your holiday dessert selection.
Get the recipe here!
For those who love tropical flavors, a Coconut Custard Pie with Coconut Whipped Cream is a fantastic choice, offering a light and airy texture with rich coconut notes. And for cookie enthusiasts, a classic Cookies and Cream Pie is always a hit.
Cookies and Cream Pie
This light and creamy Oreo pie is an absolute crowd-pleaser, perfect for anyone who loves cookies! It features fluffy whipped cream gently folded into a sweetened cream cheese mixture with chopped Oreos mixed throughout. This incredibly easy no-bake recipe is a delightful addition to any celebration, ensuring smiles all around.
Get the recipe here!
Continuing the Oreo theme, Asphalt Pie is one of the easiest and most delicious Thanksgiving pies, especially for those seeking a no-bake option. It combines an Oreo crust, mint chocolate chip ice cream, whipped topping, and a generous drizzle of caramel sauce. No baking is required—just assemble and serve for a wonderfully refreshing dessert.
Asphalt Pie
Oh, how we adore this pie! This no-bake wonder is incredibly simple and utterly delightful. It features a homemade Oreo pie crust filled with creamy mint chocolate chip ice cream, then generously topped with whipped cream, luscious caramel, and crushed Oreos. It’s a refreshing and easy dessert to enjoy all year, but especially popular during the holidays.
Get the recipe here!
Brownie Pie
For serious chocolate enthusiasts, this brownie pie recipe is a dream come true. Imagine fudgy, rich brownies baked into a flaky pie crust, complete with that iconic crackly top we all love. It’s an irresistible dessert that perfectly blends the comforting texture of a brownie with the elegance of a pie, making it a standout holiday treat.
Get the recipe here!
Add a delightful twist to a traditional favorite with a Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie. The inclusion of chocolate chips elevates the classic pecan pie, offering an extra layer of sweetness and richness that appeals to even more palates. Use dark chocolate chips for a truly decadent experience.
Essential Pie Crust Recipes
A truly great pie starts with a phenomenal crust. Whether you prefer a sturdy graham cracker base or a flaky, buttery pastry, mastering your pie crust is key to holiday baking success. Explore our favorite foolproof pie crust recipes, designed to complement any filling and simplify your preparation.
Graham Cracker Crust
This is our go-to graham cracker crust recipe, delivering perfection every single time. It’s incredibly versatile, suitable for both baked and no-bake pies. Ideal for cheesecakes, key lime pies, chocolate pies, peanut butter pies, and fruit fillings, this crust offers a sweet, crunchy foundation that enhances any dessert.
Get the recipe here!
Shortbread Pie Crust Recipe
Craft a delicate and buttery base for your favorite fillings with this flaky shortbread pie crust recipe. Its rich, crumbly texture adds a gourmet touch to any pie, from creamy custards to vibrant fruit fillings. This versatile crust is a delightful choice for those seeking an elegant and flavorful foundation for their holiday desserts.
Get the recipe here!
Food Processor Pie Crust
Streamline your pie preparation with this all-butter food processor pie crust. This recipe simplifies the process, yielding a tender, incredibly flaky crust with minimal effort. Making enough for two pie crusts, it’s perfect for tackling multiple holiday pies in one go, saving you valuable time in the kitchen.
Get the recipe here!
Oreo Pie Crust Recipe
For the ultimate chocolate indulgence, swap your standard crust for this easy and delicious Oreo pie crust. It’s perfect for chocolate lovers and incredibly versatile. Any recipe that calls for a graham cracker crust can typically be enhanced with this rich, crumbly Oreo base, adding a depth of flavor that’s truly irresistible.
Get the recipe here!
Biscoff Pie Crust
Add a unique and spiced flavor profile to your pies with this fantastic Biscoff pie crust. Made from crushed Biscoff cookies, it offers a warm, caramelized taste that pairs beautifully with pumpkin, apple, chocolate, or even key lime fillings. This delightful cookie crust is a fun and flavorful alternative for your holiday baking.
Get the recipe here!
Mastering Make-Ahead Thanksgiving Pies
Reducing your workload on Thanksgiving Day is a game-changer. One of the best ways to achieve a stress-free holiday is by preparing your pies in advance. With a little planning, you can bake delicious homemade pies without the last-minute rush, allowing you to truly enjoy the festivities. Here are some invaluable tips for making your Thanksgiving pie preparation seamless:
- Prepare Your Pie Crusts Early: Start by making your graham cracker pie crust or all-butter pie crust days or even weeks before Thanksgiving. This simple step saves significant time on the main event day. Many crusts can be made and stored in the refrigerator or freezer, ready for when you need them.
- Strategic Pie Selection for Serving Temperature: Understanding which pies are best served warm versus chilled is crucial for efficient planning. Pies like traditional apple pie are often enjoyed warm, suggesting they be baked on Thanksgiving Day or reheated before serving. In contrast, chilled desserts such as key lime pie or chocolate cream pie benefit from ample refrigeration, making them perfect make-ahead options that can be prepared a day or two in advance.
- Create a Diverse Pie Menu: Diversify your pie offerings by including a variety that can be prepared at different times. For instance, bake a frozen pie like frozen asphalt pie a week or more beforehand. Prepare a chilled, no-bake pie like our no-bake peanut butter pie the day before. Save just one or two pies that are meant to be served warm, such as a salted caramel apple pie, for baking on Thanksgiving Day. This staggered approach will significantly ease your holiday baking schedule.
Storing Your Pies for Freshness
Proper storage is essential to maintain the quality and safety of your homemade pies. Knowing the best practices for refrigeration and room temperature storage will help keep your desserts delicious for longer.
Pies to Store at Room Temperature
Most fruit pies made primarily with sugar can be safely stored at room temperature for 1-2 days. Ensure they are covered loosely to protect them from dust and air. If you’ve prepared pie crusts ahead of time, cookie crusts like graham cracker or Oreo crusts can be stored at room temperature for 2-3 days or in the refrigerator for 3-5 days.
Pies to Store in the Fridge
Any pie containing dairy or eggs, such as pumpkin pies, pecan pie, and all no-bake cream pies, should always be stored covered in the refrigerator. This practice prevents spoilage and extends freshness. As a general rule of thumb, refrigerating all pies, regardless of ingredients, will help them keep better and for a longer duration.
Freezing Pies: A Smart Strategy
Freezing pies is an excellent way to prepare well in advance and enjoy homemade goodness whenever you wish. Here’s how to properly freeze different types of pies for optimal results:
- Freezing Unbaked Butter Pie Crusts: Once your butter pie crust is neatly pressed into the pie pan, you can freeze it unbaked for 1-2 months. Tightly wrap the pie plate in plastic wrap, then an additional layer of aluminum foil. When you’re ready to bake, simply remove it from the freezer and follow your recipe’s baking instructions, adding a few extra minutes to the baking time if needed.
- Freezing Pies Before Baking: For fruit pies you intend to bake, freezing them before baking can be very effective. Flash freeze the assembled pie in the freezer until solid (this usually takes about 30 minutes to an hour). Then, remove it and double-wrap it tightly in plastic wrap, followed by a single layer of aluminum foil. Store in the freezer for 1-2 months. When it’s time to bake, remove the pie from the freezer and bake directly from its frozen state; do not thaw beforehand.
- Freezing No-Bake Pies: If your no-bake pie will be topped with whipped cream or other fresh garnishes before serving, freeze it without these toppings. Flash freeze the pie until it is firm. Once firm, double-wrap it in plastic wrap and then in aluminum foil, storing it in the freezer for 1-2 months. To serve, let it thaw at room temperature until it is chilled but no longer frozen. Add your fresh toppings, such as whipped cream or fruit, just before serving for the best presentation and taste.
We hope this guide inspires your holiday baking and helps you create a memorable and delicious Thanksgiving. Don’t forget to share your baking successes with us!
If you made one of these recipes, we’d love to hear about it! Please scroll down below the recipe section to leave a star rating and review.
Stay up-to-date with our latest recipes and tips by following us on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, and Pinterest.